The body-builder silhouette |
Can “a silhouette, represented in black, of a person adopting a typical body-building pose displaying the muscles of his body” be registered as a trade mark for – among other things – nutritional supplements, clothing, and footwear?
As Katfriend Nedim Malovic (@malovicSE) explains, this very question has been recently addressed by the General Court.
Here’s what Nedim writes:
“In its judgmenton 29 September 2016 (Universal Protein Supplements Corp v European Union Intellectual Property Office Case, T-335/15, EU:T:2016:579) the General Court upheld the decision of the Fifth Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) concerning an application to register a figurative sign representing a body-builder as a EU trade mark for the following classes of goods and services, and descriptions:
Class 5: ‘Nutritional supplements’;
Class 25: ‘Clothing; footwear’;
Class 35: ‘On-line retail store services featuring nutritional supplements; health and diet-related products; clothing and footwear’.
Class 25: ‘Clothing; footwear’;
Class 35: ‘On-line retail store services featuring nutritional supplements; health and diet-related products; clothing and footwear’.
Background
In 2014 the applicant, Universal Protein Supplements Corp, filed an application with the EUIPO to have the EU territory designed in respect of the international registration of a figurative sign representing a body-builder. The application was for goods and services in the classes indicated above.
The EUIPO examiner rejected the application, on grounds that the mark lacked any distinctive character and was descriptive for the purpose of Article 7(1)(c) of Regulation No 207/2009 on the (now) European Union Trade Mark (EUTMR).
In late 2014 Universal Protein appealed the examiner’s decision.
The EUIPO Fifth Board of Appeal dismissed the appeal in March 2015. It held that the message conveyed by the sign related to ‘body-building’ or a ‘body-builder’ and that the relevant public would perceive a direct and specific link between the sign and the goods and services designated by the mark applied for.
The Board of Appeal concluded that such mark fell within the prohibition laid down in Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR. Furthermore, the mark was devoid of any distinctive character within the meaning of Article 7(1) (b) EUTMR, on the ground that it merely consisted of a representation of a body-builder, which would not enable the relevant public to perceive it as an indication of the commercial origin of the goods and services in question.
Universal Protein did not however lose hope, and decided to appeal the decision before the General Court. It claimed that: (i) the Fifth Board of Appeal had failed to consider the mark as a whole; (ii) that its own image of the body-builder has several meanings and conveys a message that goes beyond that of a ‘body-builder’ or ‘body-building’, and (iii) that securing registration would not impair the public interest aim that descriptive signs are not monopolised by economic operators.
The National Lottery silhouette |
Analysis
The General court began by examining whether Universal Protein’s mark should be considered descriptive.
Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR pursues a public interest aim. Referring to Agencja Wydawnicza Technopol, the court recalled that a sign that is descriptive of the characteristics of the relevant goods or services ought to be freely available for use. In addition, a sign of this kind fails to fulfil the essential function of a trade mark, ie to identify the commercial origin of one’s own goods or services.
The General Court then stated that the descriptive nature of a sign is only to be assessed, (1) by reference to the way in which it is perceived by the relevant public, and (2) by reference to the goods or services concerned:
(1) Having regard to the relevant goods and services (nutritional supplements, clothing, footwear and online retail services relating to those goods) and considering that the mark is strictly figurative and lacks any verbal element, the average consumer – obviously reasonably well informed and reasonably observant and circumspect – is the public of the entire European Union. This said, because the sign consists of a typical body-builder, displaying the muscles of his body, represented in black silhouette, the message conveyed by that sign would relate to body-building.
(2) The chosen goods and services in Classes 5 (nutritional supplements), 25 (clothing; footwear), and 35 (online retail store services featuring nutritional supplements; health and diet-related products; clothing and shoes), are all indicative that the mark applied for has a sufficiently direct and specific link with nutritional supplements, clothing, footwear, and online retail store services of those goods and goods related to health and diet. According to the court, even if the categories of goods and services at issue were to also include services with no link to body-building and that, accordingly, the sign at issue were not descriptive of all the goods and services in those categories, the applicant had applied for the registration of the sign at issue for each of these as a whole without making any distinction. Accordingly, the body-builder sign would fall within the prohibition set by Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.
Contrary to the applicant’s claims, the court found that the alleged aesthetic character of the stylised image does not require any mental effort on behalf of the relevant public. The meaning of the sign at issue (which refers to the concept of ‘body-builder’ or ‘body-building’) is immediately clear. By referring to earlier case law, the court added that, even assuming that a sign has several meanings, if at least one of the meanings designates a characteristic of the goods concerned, then that sign must be equally refused.
Merpel's silhouette |
The applicant’s further claim that there would be no general interest in requiring that a representation such as that in the present case be available because there are practically unlimited ways of depicting body-builders was regarded as irrelevant. In that respect, the court noted (as also previously stated by the EUIPO) that, according to settled case-law, the application of Article 7(1)(c) of the EUTMR does not depend on the existence of a real, current or serious need to leave a sign free.
The Board of Appeal was therefore correct in concluding that the sign in question is descriptive for the purpose of Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.
All this said, the court considered unnecessary to review whether the sign at issue would be distinctive, and concluded that the body-builder silhouette could not be registered as a trade mark because of the prohibition in Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.
Conclusion
This decision appears correct from a formal standpoint, and probably the General Court was concerned with the implications of creating a monopoly over the use of a silhouette of this kind for such types of goods and services. However, in the past there have been decisions that could have supported a different outcome. For instance, it is unclear why the silhouette of a body-builder should be descriptive of nutritional supplements, while a hand with a smile and crossed fingers should not suggest “best of luck” and describe what the concept of lottery is all about. Yet, the National Lottery ‘hand’ was successfully registered as a EU trade mark.”
Read More: QuickBooks Error 1603
BalasHapusI feel so elated to go through your blog. Every time I come across any of your blogs, I find myself in short of words to describe the uniqueness and the manner of representation. Amongst the various available websites and posts, I prefer a few and yours’ is one of them.
Here, I am giving a reference to the world-class, customer-friendly and outstanding technical service providers. Besides being highly inclined towards customers’ service, their team consists of members who are highly skilled and qualified through their work experience of years. Be sure to dial the QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number +1 833-228-2822.
Read More: QuickBooks Error 3003
QuickBooks Error H202
BalasHapusHey, greetings and applause for your excellent post. You never fail to provide quality information in an appropriate quantity. I must say you must be consistent in this activity of yours. Hey, if you are a QuickBooks user, then pay attention to my advice. Consult the best tech support service providers for 24*7 services at QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number +1 833-228-2822.
QuickBooks Error 1603
In case we miss your call i.e. mostly at the time of tax filing, we assure that we will revert back to you in as less time as possible. So, call us at our toll-free QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-844-200-2627 and enjoy our customer friendly, round the clock assistance. get assisted by our experts through remote desktop support process. Our Average Response time is 6 seconds.for more information visit our website-QuickBooks Support Phone Number
BalasHapusFacing difficulty while installing your QuickBooks software? Get assistance from certified technicians, Simply dial our QuickBooks Support Phone Number 1-844-200-2627 and get effective solutions to resolve QuickBooks installation errors. For more information read our blog QuickBooks Support Number.
BalasHapusFacing difficulty while installing your QuickBooks software? Get assistance from certified technicians, Simply dial our QuickBooks Support Phone Number 1-844-200-2627 and get effective solutions to resolve QuickBooks installation errors. For more information read our blog QuickBooks Support Number.
BalasHapusThis is a well-drafted piece of information. I would like to appreciate you for your seamless efforts for delivering such a readable post. Of course, QuickBooks is important to manage the business. What if you face problems while working with it? With my suggestion, you can discuss your doubts with experts on the team. Make sure to interact with the experts regarding your technical queries. You can report your concerns and avail required support at QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-800-311-5657.
BalasHapusHey, I just went through your blog and immediately subscribed to it. I haven’t gone through
BalasHapusmany of your posts. If you need to manage your business, then download QuickBooks. Contact
the support team for every QuickBooks assistance. The team is available for service at
QuickBooks Mac Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
Hey, I just went through your blog and immediately subscribed to it. I haven’t gone through
BalasHapusmany of your posts. If you need to manage your business, then download QuickBooks. Contact
the support team for every QuickBooks assistance. The team is available for service at
QuickBooks Mac Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
Hey, it is an amazing blog. I just loved the quality content you have shared. Thanks for this share
BalasHapusand keep growing. I hope your working with QuickBooks would just be fine. I have a reference
for QuickBooks assistance. Just report your related concerns at QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
Hey, it is an amazing blog. I just loved the quality content you have shared. Thanks for this share
BalasHapusand keep growing. I hope your working with QuickBooks would just be fine. I have a reference
for QuickBooks assistance. Just report your related concerns at QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
QuickBooks is one of the most sought-after accounting software that helps you to manage and control your entire cash –flow of your business. Besides the countless benefits, QuickBooks Software is also prone to technical Bugs and Errors. So, if you ever get in the trap of any issues or bugs on QuickBooks contact us via our QuickBooks Support Phone Number USA +1-844-200-2627 and get efficient solutions.
BalasHapusHey! Wonderful Post,
BalasHapusBeautiful composition of informative ideas. I like your commendable work! Keep up the good
and effective work my friend. Could you please post some more blogs on the same topic? In
today’s world, businesses are enhancing their productivity and service with the help of
QuickBooks Software. It has absolutely made the task of accounting and bookkeeping easy-
going and possible to perform in just a few clicks. Along with these beneficial features, you can
also get the best support at our QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
Hey! Wonderful Post,
BalasHapusBeautiful composition of informative ideas. I like your commendable work! Keep up the good
and effective work my friend. Could you please post some more blogs on the same topic? In
today’s world, businesses are enhancing their productivity and service with the help of
QuickBooks Software. It has absolutely made the task of accounting and bookkeeping easy-
going and possible to perform in just a few clicks. Along with these beneficial features, you can
also get the best support at our QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996.
For any QuickBooks Related Query, contact us at ourQuickBooks Helpline Number +1-844-200-2627, to get rid of all QuickBooks errors. We provide step-by-step solution for all errors. Our support has minimum charges with zero assistance fee.
BalasHapusHi Friend,
BalasHapusAwesome Post, this is truly an awe-inspiring post my friend and delight to the readers. The
authenticity of this post is damn high. This work of yours is appreciated, keep the hard work
going. QuickBooks Payroll Support running payroll for small businesses easy and hassle-free.
You can buy this Payroll software from a reliable source and start enhancing your business
instantly. Like any other software, this software is also bounded by bugs and errors and thus
you encounter any such infamous bugs you can call us at our QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-235-3996 and responsively get rid of the errors by our experts.visit us:-https://tinyurl.com/y28zf34j
I would like to share my sincere feedback with you. You have presented a very well-drafted and acknowledgeable content. The facts are highly relevant and so accurate. So, I just shared your work without any second opinion. Keep growing and succeeding further. If you need reliable technical services for QuickBooks, then I have the best option for you. Get familiar with QuickBooks through world-class services. You can also apply for technical aids concerning problems at the QuickBooks Tech Support Number +1-800-272-7634. Visit here: https://medium.com/@johnmocus8001/dial-quickbooks-tech-support-number-1-800-272-7634-for-prompt-quickbooks-solutions-206b2596971e
BalasHapus
BalasHapusBuy weed online
Buy cannabis online
Buy marijuana online
BalasHapusBuy marijuana online
Dial QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-8OO-484-5676 And Get the Remote Desktop Help for QuickBooks. Don’t hesitate to call us at QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-8OO-484-5676 and get the immediate resolution of errors in the shortest time span.
BalasHapusQuickBooks Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number
BalasHapusbuy used outboard motors
best place to buy outboard motors
buy outboard motors
where to buy outboard motors rushford ny
can i buy a gun with my birth certificate
where can i buy a birth certificate online in florida
buy a blank irish birth certificate
2-fluoroamphetamine
buy 2 fa online ( 2-fluoroamphetamine for sale online )buy 2 fma online
1p-lsd blotters
blueberry kush dank vapes
fruity pebbles dank vapes
lsd dank vapes
my naked dolls
passion dolls
mini love doll
anime sex toy
life size dolls
guy fucks sex doll
sexy dolls
buy counterfeit money over darknet
buy counterfeit money from china
buy counterfeit paper money from china
celebrity sex dolls
1am dolls
how to refill dank vape cartridge
dank vapes gorilla glue
dank vapes gsc
dank vapes cartridge
dank thc oil
dank vape cartridges
buy usa id cards online
buy-fake-id-cards-online/
medical marijuana id cards online to buy in all states
buy fake id cards online
buy id cards online
dank thc cartridge
100% thc cartridge for sale
dank oil cartridges
lemon skunk dank vapes
gsc dank vapes
dank vape cart
Very well explained blog. It is very helpful for learner. click here for
BalasHapusQuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number USA to get 24*7 QuickBooks customer Service and QuickBooks technical support for more detail dial on our QuickBooks support number 844-908-0801
Alternatives Tips
BalasHapusSamsung Galaxy S7 Vs S7 Edge
Best PSP Games
Best Ps1 Games
Destiny 2 Xur
Best Torrent Client
Best Chest Workout
Nice Blog!
BalasHapusKnow More About QuickBooks general ledger? Get live support 24*7 from QuickBooks expert on tool-free Number.
Click here to know How to QuickBooks general ledger
Dial for any tech support: 1-844-908-0801
Puff bars are the current leaders in the nicotine vaping world. The puff bar flavors are numerous and everyone with a unique taste has a choice to make. A variety of categories like the Puff bar plus and Puff flow further ease the selection. Flavors of the famous brand include; Menthol, Cool Mint, Mango, and many more.
BalasHapusIstana Istimewa Paling tinggi di Dunia – https://pesona-wisata.com/ Istana Potala sebagai bangunan yang dipandang seperti landmark dan lambang Tibet.
BalasHapusBangunan ini sebagai istana besar yang terbagi dalam beberapa rumah, menara, kapel, dan lain-lain.